A Concise Answer to Ido Aharoni’s Query ‘Why Boycott Israel?’ (27 June 2013) By Lawrence Davidson


Alice Walker


Ido Aharoni, Israel’s Consul General for New York, and also “the founding head of Israel’s brand-management team and the originator of the Brand Israel movement” recently wrote an op-ed in the New York Post (19 June 2013). In it he took to task the famous American novelist Alice Walker for her promotion of a cultural boycott of Israel.


Aharoni explains that, just like most countries in the world, Israel tries to promote “an attractive image”of itself – a sort of Israeli version of “I love New York.” Since, “no other country has ever been criticized for engaging in this common practice of courting tourists and businesses” why does Walker try to interfere with Israel’s branding campaign?


Ahroni knows full well why Walker does so. However, for him the racism and oppression Walker sees institutionalized in Israeli society is not a good reason for a boycott. Ahroni asserts that “Israel, like many places on Earth, experiences a variety of issues and challenges. . . .Israel should not be viewed through the prism of its problems, nor should any other country.” On the other hand, Ahroni wants to know why Walker is not boycotting Syria?


The question of why Americans should boycott Israel in particular, when so many other governments and societies in the world are oppressive and brutal, is an important one. And there is indeed a good answer to it:


The fact that Zionist influence spreads far beyond Israel’s area of dominion and now influences many of the policy making institutions of western governments, and particularly that of the United States, makes it imperative that Israel’s oppressive behavior be singled out as a high priority case for boycott. In other words, unlike other oppressive and brutal governments, the Israelis and their supporters directly influence (one might say corrupt) the policy makers of many Western nations and this often makes their governments (most specifically the U.S.) accomplices in Israel’s abusive policies. This being so, prioritizing Israel for boycott is not hypocrisy but rather necessity.

2 Responses to “A Concise Answer to Ido Aharoni’s Query: Why Boycott Israel?”

  • Catherine:

    What makes Western governments, namely the US, vulnerable to Zionist influence? Why are we even having to dialogue about culturally boycotting Israel? I’m asking to go beyond AIPAC-what is at the heart of this defense? Or is it simply that at the heart of this is money and it’s use to influence? If that is the case, then perhaps the case of Israel is simply a manifestation of our OWN problem. The question then becomes why are we not culturally boycotting OURSELVES!

    Following the argument line that there is a money trail here, not a philosophical alignment with Zionism, then the trail will lead us to what? Capitalists that we are, I’m guessing there are Western industrial enterprises at work here…such as the weapons industry, the intelligence industry, natural resource industries, international trade. Perhaps Israel is simply a commodity for the West-one that we spend billions in for R&D, development and distribution to apathetic consumers. Once we start talking about the value proposition of Israel, then we’ll begin to unpack our allegiance/investment in this commodity and I argue the BOYCOTT is of OUR Western capitalistic culture.

Leave a Reply